90 Day Fiancé is arguably one of the most unique reality shows on the small screen right now. Its kooky concept has been a big success with audiences, too, leading the TLC Network to create a franchise. And during one of the show’s most popular runs, fans were both captivated and shocked by a participant named David Murphey. You see, viewers were convinced that David was the victim of a diabolical catfishing scam – but was too lovesick to see it. But when the real story was finally revealed, the audience was left in total shock.